Stay Informed

How To Fight Animal Rights Extremists And Their Threats

EmailPrint

Bill Hemby
Chairman, PetPAC

AB 1634 surfaced in California during the first part of 2007. The State Assembly Bill was introduced by a liberal Democratic State Assemblyman Lloyd Levine, from Southern California . Mr. Levine, thanks in no small part to you, is no longer a state legislator. In its original form the bill called for mandatory spay and neuter of all dogs and cats 4 months of age, unless you had dispensation from your veterinarian for health reasons. Even that was temporary. There were other exemptions, none of which made much sense.

The bill was supported by animal rights organizations, particularly one led by Ms. Judi Mancuso, a self-appointed pontificator of the more radical side of animal rights extremists. Mancuso is in league with PETA, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals A head count showed about 250 animal rights groups in support. Ms. Mancuso consistently displayed exaggeration and hysteria as well as questionable data. As a public relations gimmick they called AB 1634 “The Healthy Pets Act”.

AB 1634 submitted by a senior legislator from the majority party was on a fast track for passage. I attended the first hearing and found our side in a bit of disarray.

That's when I decided to create PetPAC, a grass roots political organization of pet owners and pet organizations. I believed, my background both as a legislative advocate in California and Washington DC, as well as an avid dog owner, exhibitor and breeder for the past 25 years could serve me well to enter this fray. I knew we would need a political solution. It would require a professional team to put together a strategy, and run it like a political campaign.

PetPAC had to be a broad coalition of supporters from across both the dog and cat worlds. The days of fighting these legislative battles in a piecemeal fashion as a volunteer dog or cat club were over. If we wanted to win, it would require a well-funded, long-term commitment by a political coalition. That is what PetPAC became.

AB 1634 support funding came from such organizations as the Humane Society of the United States , ( HSUS) People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, (PETA) and other animal rights extremist groups, Well meaning animal rights advocates and the well to do from our entertainment industry also contributed.

PetPAC hit the ground running. As AB 1634 was moving rapidly, there wasn't time for long term planning. The PetPAC group met daily and with our own money, put together a new 501(c) 4 corporation, a professional website, a post office box, an office, and telephones. We started to develop a strategy to stop the bill.

The first problem was message. AB 1634 supporters tagged pure bred dog breeders as the culprits. Levine and company, painted the pure bred fancy as: “dog and cat breeders who made millions of dollars selling puppies and kittens, paid no taxes, and were the main contributors to filling animal shelters with unwanted pets. According to the proponents, this led to pet overpopulation, over crowding in our animal shelters and the killing of millions of dogs and cats.

They manipulated statistics to show mandatory spay and neuter programs resulted in reducing shelter costs by $250 million, reduced euthanasia, and cut the animal population. Our research showed an entirely different picture. Their numbers were wrong, their results were lies and there was no cost savings. In fact, the data showed the opposite.

Everywhere we looked, mandatory spay and neuter programs resulted in lost revenue due to pet licensing rates plummeting. Animal shelters populations increased because owners facing a huge fine disavowed ownership of their dogs, returning them to shelters. Once the dog or cat is gone, they go down the street and buy a new one. This was later confirmed by the California Department of Finance.

Euthanasia rates increased as shelters acquired more animals. The cost of operating shelters climbed as licensing fell and penalties were not forthcoming. This resulted in higher license fees for animal owners, which exacerbated the situation all over again.

Shelter costs are mostly personnel costs (90% in Los Angeles City ) so there is no cost savings, even if shelter rates decrease, which they won't.

The public resents and rebels against the invasion of privacy inherent with MSN.

Veterinarians oppose MSN because it destroys the vet/client relationship required for animal health.

Spay/Neuter is a matter between the pet owner and his/her veterinarian, not a matter of government intervention.

PetPAC produced a message that disputed the AR propaganda. We traveled the state preaching at dog and cat shows, club meetings, radio talk shows, We produced two professional TV ads and posted thousands of emails to our supporters. We produced brochures and delivered them all across the country. We met with legislators and staff on numerous occasions to hammer home our arguments. We held public rallies in Sacramento and encouraged thousands to write, telephone and fax their legislators. And it started to work.

At one point in July of 2007, PetPAC and other groups generated over 10,000 telephone calls, letters and faxes to Sacramento lawmakers. The day of the hearing we practically shut down the state capitol. That hearing resulted in the first defeat of AB 1634. The bill was held in committee.

The battle raged on for another year. PetPAC continued its fight. Our number of supporters increased to 45,000. Finally, during the last weeks of session, AB 1634 was soundly defeated by the California State Senate, 27 to 5.

In California , cities and counties are rethinking MSN.

Huntington Beach, Santa Barbara County , Kern County have shelved it. Public outrage over invasion of privacy, punitive laws and heavy handed treatment is making itself felt on city government.

So, how do you fight the AR’s?

First: Do Not Fall Into Denial!

“Hey!, That’s stupid. It will never pass!” “No one in his right mind would vote for that!”

Well, you’re wrong. MSN, Breed Specific Legislatiion and Pet limits are springing up everywhere across the United States . At least one of these issues is before a local or state legislature in all 50 states.

MSN has already passed in parts of Florida, Texas, Colorado, California, and New Mexico. BSL is on the rise, as are pet limitation ordinances. So, the first thing you have to do is understand this is a serious issue, led by a determined, well-funded group. Usually, because these groups have wormed their way into the legislative process, time is of the essence.

Second: Get Over The Fear!

Don't be like a deer caught in the headlights. “Oh My! Oh My!” “What to do?” “What to do?” Stop wringing your hands! You Are Not Alone. Pick up the phone and call your friends. You are not the first ones to have to fight this battle. There are literally millions of sympathetic animal owners out there who will join with you and help.

Do not wait for a saviour. No one is going to come down from on high to make this go away.

Essentially, you and those like you are the soldiers of this battle. Make the decision the major effort will fall on your shoulders. But think about it. Anyone who has belonged to a pet club has volunteered to put on a show, do trophies, provide a lunch, do transportation, and the myriad of other chores it takes to put a show together. You have the skills, You are competitive, You are intelligent. If you weren’t, you wouldn’t even realize what a threat MSN is.

Ok So What Now?

1). What is the threat?

Get a copy of the actual proposed legislation, ordinance or directive. Read it. Understand it. If you don’t understand it, how can you explain it to others? Is this a measure to go after barking dogs? Is this a move to increase fees? Is this a breed ban? Just what is the threat?

Go On the Internet! 9 times out of 10, this issue is not original thinking. Somewhere there are similar laws, ordinances or directives that this one came from. In every instance, MSN follows the guidelines of AB 1634. Send it out to others, especially anyone in the legal profession. Get others to read the proposal. Get input as to the ramifications of the law. How will this affect your lifestyle? How much could this cost? What’s the worse case scenario? Who is behind it? What is their bottom line?

Contact your legislative body. Clerks are very helpful, and are not the enemy. Just remember, most of them are pet owners too. A lot will be sympathetic. You can glean intelligence from those who work for legislators. Find out when, where, and how legislative meetings are held and conducted. How are speakers selected? Who can speak? How long can they speak? What about petitions? Find out the background of every legislator that will make the decision on this law. Find out if they are for or against. This may be hard to do, but you can get an inkling from conversations with staff. Are they hunters? Do they or their family own pets? Do they show? Are they a vegan? Do they support PETA? Are they a sponsor of the bill?

Ask who the sponsor is. What person, group, or groups are behind this? Look them up on line. Who is behind this group? Where is the Animal Control Services in all this? Do they oppose or support the measure? Who in that group (the Director?), is pushing this? Read their reports. They should be published in some form, maybe a report to the Board of Supervisors? The City Council?

Find out the time-line of this bill. How much time do you actually have?

Call a meeting of people you know in your dog club, dog /cat owners in your neighborhood, friends, family. Don’t discard anyone because you may think they aren’t interested, or are not joiners.

At the meeting lay out the threat. Lay out any background or history you have collected. Create a grass roots group. Citizens Against Pet Extinction. Coalition for the Love of our Pets; Stop Mandatory Pet Sterilization. Join PetPAC. We did it already. Use our tactics.

Appoint individuals or groups to do research. What are the statistics behind this issue? Are they accurate? Don’t just accept anything the supporters put out there. Most of the time they are innacurrate, overstated and out right lies. Appoint another group to do fund raising. Raise money, Raise money. Raise money. I cannot stress that enough. Put together a finance committee who do nothing but raise funds. After all, you are working on behalf of all pet owners, not just yourself.

You may need someone or a group to make signs, to call politicians, to call other pet people, to call local pet businesses. Find links to influential business people in your community who might lend support. The Chamber of Commerce, The Real Estate Board. Get letter writing, faxing, email, telephone campaigns going. Get the word out throughout your region, your state, the country. Enlist the support of other groups, ie. Hunting, sporting, cattle industry, farm bureau, law enforcement.

Affiliate with PetPAC. This is a political battle. It will be won or lost through political action. PetPAC has the expertise, the background and the knowledge to help. Go to: www.petpac.net.

Contact local and regional dog and cat clubs. Solicit their help. Solicit funds. Ask for opposition letters.

Contact every local Real Estate office and explain, as Realtors they have a fiduciary responsibility to tell prospective home buyers that their animals must be spayed and neutered if they buy in your area, or they will only be able to have X-number of pets in their household, or their dog breed may be already outlawed.

Contact local vets and ask them to oppose. If they hem and haw, tell them you will be down to pick up a letter of opposition or all of your pets files so you can find a new vet.

Design your message. There are reams of written statements, reports and fact sheets available on line for each of these issues. Design your message, try it out, look for faults, see if it resonates within your group. Redraft it, then stick to it. Do not go off message.

Create a website and urge everyone opposed to visit your website and then capture those email addresses for future email information as well as solicitation of funds, Link your site to www.petpac.net. (if you can't put up a website, send them to the www.petpac.net website. They can download fliers, and information that can be changed to fit your location and circumstances.

Put together a core group of dog/cat activists to lead the charge. find anyone with graphic skills, computer skills, writing skills, P/R backgrounds, organizing,

STAY ON MESSAGE

Everyone stays on message. Do not go off on a tangent.

Yes, this is wrong. It may be unconstitutional, It certainly may be an invasion of your privacy, and your rights as a citizen. But, unless you have money to burn, hold off on the lawsuits. Groups in California have spent over $100,000 already in court costs and have not won.

Research the proposal to see if there is any "conflict of interest" within the council. In Huntington Beach, California , Debbie Bent and Teddi Alves of POWER found out the main mover of their ordinance and his wife were closely aligned with a rescue/spay-neuter group that had received over $50,000 to oversee the new programs. The group was tied into PETA, (politicians would just hate that to get out to anyone.)

Have as many people as possible to contact and meet with each politician and talk with them about the down sides of the issue. Do not threaten. Be polite, even though you may want to strangle the person.

Make up fliers with all the bill’s downsides, The cost, invasiveness, anything that may hurt the public. If there is one or two intractable politicians who you already know are voting for this measure, put them on the defensive. “They hate pets!”, They have no idea what it is to love a pet!

Turn out volunteers at dog parks, dog/cat events to mobilize more opposition. Put up a booth at pet fairs, dog/cat shows, sign up everyone to your website, or send them to the PetPAC website. If you can put up tables in front of large shopping outlets, pet shops, do it. Enlist those in the pet industry to have your fliers at their business. Keep it simple. Do not load down your table with material. Only two or three fliers at the most. Have people sign a petition. Everyone likes to sign petitions. But, get their email address!!!

Contact newspapers/TV and let them know you are an active political group affiliated with a larger national group (PetPAC). Send out a Press Release. One page, get a P/R or press person to write it. Use PetPAC's name and numbers if you like.

Make up or have signs produced. It is better to have signs without handles. Brochures that can be handed out at public locations. A double sided single sheet card stock flier is best. Keep it short. The worst thing to do is ramble on and on in a flier.

Prior to any hearing, invite everyone to a rally in front of city hall. Be sure to get a permit if that is necessary. Make everyone RSVP for a head count. Contact the press a few days in advance. Write or have someone with writing skills write statements to hand to the press. Put together Press Packets made up, with your talking points or message, with a full copy of the measure, with your groups background. With statistics about this measure from other cities (only if it was defeated or was a disaster) Have a contact person listed.

Make sure you know who your speakers are. Make sure you know what they will say. This is important because we are all nervous when public speaking. You don’t want multiple speakers saying the same things. It is best to have each speaker write down their remarks and practice speaking them in front of a mirror. Take your time. You can say a lot in one or two minutes.

Again, do not threaten, be polite. Do mention if you are a resident of the community.

On the Hearing day. BE EARLY. Set up a picket line. Do speakers have to sign in? Are speakers picked at random? Do all the speakers need to sign a speaker's card? Make up stick on labels with your organization’s name, and opposition. Pick a bright color. “STOP MSN” “NO MANDATORY STERILIZATION” “STOP GOVERNMENT OVER REACH” “STOP INVASION OF PRIVACY” MANDATORY STERILIZATION OF PETS IS WRONG” Make sure someone gets inside early and sets up a section for your group.

Do not argue or shout at the other side. When supporters of the measure are speaking, do not interrupt them, do not hiss, yell, catcall, laugh. For your speakers do not clap, cheer, yell, or interrupt them. If you are asked a question, answer it, if you can, with your message. Stay on message!

If you lose the lssue, it’s not the end of the world. You can always come back to fight another day. Remember: “That which does not kill you,can only make you stronger.”

If you win, either by the Board of Council voting it down, be sure to send letters of thanks to the entire Board. Contact the local Animal Control Agency and suggest you work together on another way to achieve the same ends.

One of the main issues of proponents of MSN is the killing of animlals in our shelters. They deplore it, they shout it. PetPAC is supporting Nathan Winograd’s “No Kill” Shelter Method. “No Kill” has been shown to save over 90% of sheltered animals. This is an answer to proponents. Read Mr. Winograd’s book “Redemption”. Contact PetPAC for more information.

Please go to www.petpac.net and you can download several documents that outline our fight against MSN If I can help please contact me at: [email protected]

Bill Hemby
Chairman
PetPAC

Contribute | Tell Your Friends | Sign the Petition