Bill Hemby's Opposition Letter to the Senate
Sunday, August 17, 2008
Senator;
PetPAC, an organization representing over 44,000 pet owners and 800 dog and cat clubs is adamantly opposed to AB 1634 irrespective of new amendments.
The bottom line is PetPAC does not believe, and our research affirms, mandatory spay and neuter does not reduce dogs running at large, dogs misbehaving, vicious dogs, or dog bites. MSN does not reduce bad behaviour of irresponsible dog and cat owners.
Mandatory spay and neuter does not reduce the pet population in our animal shelters. In fact, the direct opposite occurs. The California Department of Finance agrees with our assessment. Sixty to seventy five percent of dog and cat owners faced with increased fines, penalties, surgical and microchipping costs, will disavow ownership of their animals or surrender them back to the shelter to be destroyed.
The Department of Finance report on AB 1634 says when these dogs and cats are surrendered, the state will have to reimburse local shelters for the mandated costs of extra holding days, and the surgical procedures required under AB 1634. Right now, the state owes local shelters $23 million. If AB 1634 is codified, these Hayden mandated costs will in the least double. Mandatory spay and neuter does not stop irresponsible animal ownership. AB 1634 is not the answer.
The answer lies in increased education, especially multi-lingual education. The answer lies in free and low cost spay and neuter clinics. The answer lies in adopting the “No Kill” method of running animal shelters. “No Kill” results in over a 90% save rate for our sheltered animals.
“No Kill” results in saving animals. Mandatory Spay/Neuter results in more killing, escalated state and local costs, and a failed system that has never worked. MSN disenfranchises thousands of law abiding California citizens who pay taxes and love their dogs and cats.
I urge you not to listen to supporters of AB 1634. MSN does not work. It never has worked. It allows more punishment of animals, not the owners who are not acting responsibly.
PetPAC is determined to institute “No Kill” as the accepted animal shelter method in California. I would ask you to vote No on AB 1634 and MSN. Let us have the opportunity to work with your office in drafting a “No Kill” program that has been shown to save animals, reduces shelter costs, increase adoptions, increase public donations to shelters and shelter support within its community.
Sincerely;
Bill Hemby
Chairman



